Ranking all the WWE 2K Games From Worst To Best - ReelZap (2024)

WWE, a dominant force in the world of professional wrestling, has a storied legacy of producing numerous video games that span across various gaming platforms. The collaboration with multiple developers and publishers has introduced a rich diversity in the gaming experiences offered to fans.

However, one of the most notable and enduring partnerships in recent years has been with 2K Games, which took over publishing duties for WWE games in 2013, starting with the release of WWE 2K14.

Embarking on a comprehensive exploration of the WWE 2K series reveals a riveting evolution, with each installment contributing to the dynamic narrative of virtual wrestling entertainment.

From the initial sparks in WWE 2K19 to the triumphant return with WWE 2K22, and the gradual refinements in WWE 2K23 and WWE 2K24, the series has been a canvas for developers to paint a vibrant picture, navigating the delicate balance between realism and adrenaline-pumping excitement.

Over the years, 2K Games has witnessed both triumphs and setbacks in its efforts to bring the electrifying world of WWE to gaming consoles. The trajectory of success or failure has often been gauged by the assessments provided by critics and audiences alike, with IGN’s ratings standing as a prominent benchmark for evaluating the overall quality of these games.

This article takes a closer look at the evolution of the WWE 2K series, diving into the nuanced strengths, persistent weaknesses, and the notable strides taken by the developers over the years.

WWE 2K20

The journey took a notably rocky turn with the release of WWE 2K20, a title that fell far short of expectations. Despite incremental improvements in the combat system in the preceding years, WWE 2K20 managed to unravel much of the progress achieved by its predecessors, regressing even further.

The game’s undoing lay in its subpar character designs and an avalanche of bugs that plagued the gaming experience. The resultant backlash from fans and critics alike was so overwhelming that 2K Games had to take a hiatus, stepping back to reassess its approach and focus on delivering a product that would meet the expectations of its dedicated fanbase.

WWE 2K Battlegrounds

Attempting to fill the void left by the absence of WWE 2K21, 2K Games released WWE 2K Battlegrounds, an arcade-style game aimed at offering a different flavor to WWE gaming enthusiasts.

However, the reception of Battlegrounds was tepid, earning an IGN rating of 5. The gameplay, designed to be pick-up-and-play, was criticized for its lack of depth, the art style failed to make a lasting impression, and the inclusion of numerous microtransactions left a sour taste in the mouths of players.

WWE 2K15

Prior to these recent missteps, WWE 2K15 faced challenges following the success of WWE 2K14. Expectations were high for 2K15 to build on its predecessor’s strengths, but the end result was a game that felt woefully undercooked.

Despite improvements in the user interface, the roster left much to be desired, and the visuals failed to make the same impact. Players found themselves yearning for the features and polish offered by WWE 2K14, questioning the decisions made in the development of its successor.

WWE 2K18

The struggles continued with WWE 2K18, a game that faced criticism for not justifying its existence as a standalone title. While it retained several successful elements from WWE 2K17, the MyCareer mode proved to be underwhelming, failing to engage players as expected. The promo system within the game drew strong criticism from several quarters, further contributing to the overall sense of disappointment.

As the WWE 2K series navigates through highs and lows, fans eagerly anticipate the next installment, hoping for a return to the glory days of WWE gaming. The partnership between WWE and 2K Games remains a dynamic collaboration, and with each release, there is an expectation for growth, innovation, and a more profound connection with the passionate WWE fanbase.

The journey continues, and the hope is that future WWE 2K titles will capture the essence of professional wrestling, delivering an immersive and satisfying experience that resonates with both long-time fans and those new to the world of WWE gaming.

WWE 2K19: A Glimpse of Potential

Launched with an IGN rating of 7.3, WWE 2K19 introduced several commendable features that teased the potential for greatness. The MyCareer mode witnessed significant improvements, the creation suite offered unparalleled customizability, and the Payback system injected a layer of strategic complexity into the in-ring action.

However, despite these positive steps forward, WWE 2K19 grappled with age-old issues that had plagued its predecessors. The commentary remained wooden and stilted, character progression stumbled in the main story, and an array of persistent bugs hindered the game from ascending to true greatness. While settling for ‘good’ rather than ‘great,’ WWE 2K19 laid down a foundation for potential enhancements in subsequent releases.

WWE 2K22: A Much-Needed Redemption

Following the abject failure of WWE 2K20, WWE 2K22 was a make-or-break moment for the series. Laden with the weight of expectations, the game not only redeemed the series but marked a substantial leap forward in quality, earning an IGN rating of 8. Wrestling enthusiasts breathed a collective sigh of relief as the developers showcased their commitment to crafting a quality title.

Despite persistent bugs and a slightly janky collision system, the introduction of a new grappling system and enhanced controls breathed fresh life into the franchise. The commentary received a facelift, and a fluid combo system injected dynamism into the in-ring action. WWE 2K22 successfully redeemed the series, proving that 2K was dedicated to rectifying past mistakes and ushering in a new era for virtual wrestling.

WWE 2K23: Building on Success

Opting for a path of incremental upgrades rather than a radical overhaul, WWE 2K23 continued the upward trajectory of the series. Garnering an IGN rating of 8, this installment showcased improvements across major game modes, affirming a commitment to refining existing features.

Rather than attempting to reinvent the wheel, the developers focused on fine-tuning elements that had garnered praise. The introduction of WarGames added a layer of chaotic excitement to the gameplay, reinforcing the idea that 2K was committed to steady improvement. While not revolutionary, WWE 2K23 provided enough enhancements to warrant consideration for those who had enjoyed the previous iteration.

WWE 2K24: A Refined Experience

Concluding a trilogy of great wrestling games, WWE 2K24 maintained its focus on refining what had worked well in its predecessors. Earning an IGN rating of 8, the game acknowledged and addressed issues, delivering a well-rounded experience that showcased the series hitting its stride.

The developers paid significant attention to the MyRise mode, and strategic changes in MyGM mode elevated the overall experience. WWE 2K24 demonstrated that 2K had found its rhythm, choosing to build upon the strengths of previous releases rather than take unnecessary risks.

WWE 2K17: Sacrificing Showcase for MyCareer

Despite an IGN rating of 8.2, WWE 2K17 faced scrutiny for its decision to cast aside the beloved Showcase mode in favor of MyCareer. While the impactful in-ring action and increased freedom to brawl in various locations garnered praise, the half-baked nature of MyCareer failed to justify the absence of Showcase.

While the core gameplay remained immensely enjoyable, the void left by Showcase left players with unfulfilled expectations, underscoring the delicate balance developers must strike between innovation and meeting fan expectations.

WWE 2K14: A Stellar Debut

2K’s initial foray into the world of WWE gaming with WWE 2K14 showcased a keen understanding of what wrestling fans desired – a chance to relive the greatness of iconic moments. With an impressive IGN rating of 8.7, the game introduced the phenomenal 30 Years of WrestleMania mode, coupled with an extensive creation suite.

This combination allowed players to delve deep into WWE’s vast catalog, reliving unforgettable moments and customizing the experience to their heart’s content. While not without its imperfections, WWE 2K14 set the series on the right path, establishing a solid foundation for future releases.

WWE 2K16: The Near-Perfect Wrestling Experience

Marking a pinnacle for the series, WWE 2K16 earned an exceptional IGN rating of 8.8. The game went to great lengths to provide fans with an authentic wrestling experience that remained incredibly fun to play. A restructured reversal system and improved working holds granted players more flexibility, enabling them to control the pace of the action.

WWE 2K16 successfully balanced realism with entertainment, offering fans nearly everything they desired in a wrestling game. The game’s meticulous attention to detail and focus on delivering an engaging experience cemented its status as a near-perfect wrestling simulation.

The WWE 2K series has navigated a dynamic landscape, learning from its missteps and building upon its successes. From the potential glimpsed in WWE 2K19 to the redemption of WWE 2K22, the steady improvements in WWE 2K23 and WWE 2K24, and the highs and lows of WWE 2K17, WWE 2K14, and WWE 2K16, each installment has played a crucial role in shaping the series.

As fans eagerly anticipate the next release, the journey through the years reveals a series dedicated to delivering a captivating virtual wrestling experience, constantly evolving to meet the expectations of its passionate fanbase. The WWE 2K series stands as a testament to the industry’s ability to adapt, innovate, and continuously strive for excellence in the realm of virtual sports entertainment.